![]()
James is the COO of Build Grow Scale has been in the e-commerce industry for over a decade, and specifically on the Shopify platform. James has worked with every niche on the planet, and he’s had the blessing to work with every size of client, from startup to the multiple 8- to 10-figure brands.
Highlight Bullets
- Expanding an Amazon business to Shopify and other sales channels
- Setting up a Shopify store and integrating fulfillment
- Driving store traffic through SEO, Google Shopping, and paid ads
- Differentiating a brand and building customer trust in an AI-driven market
- Improving conversion rates through clear messaging, navigation, and page design
- Modern CRO practices, including calls to action, consistent design, and transparent upsells
- Structuring store content for search engines and AI-powered shopping tools
- Using backlinks, useful content, and customer questions to support organic visibility
- Using analytics, heatmaps, and customer feedback to guide decisions and tests
- Managing experimentation, risk, and incremental improvements to scale a brand
A Shopify store can generate sales without a blog, but James says one store brought in about $80,000 in sales attributed to AI search in just 90 days. On the Ecomm Breakthrough Podcast, Build Growth Scale’s James joins Josh Hadley to explain how Amazon sellers can expand to Shopify without building an “Amazon page” all over again. They discuss why real photography and clear messaging matter more in an era of AI-built storefronts, which page-level metrics to track, and why James says he loses more tests than he wins. His practical advice: let customer behavior and data, not personal preferences, guide what you change.
Here are 3 action items that Josh identified from this episode:
- Make Your Store Feel Human
Don’t let AI make your brand look generic. Use real photos, videos, customer content, and authentic brand messaging. - Prioritize Clarity Over Cleverness
Make it immediately clear who you are, what you sell, and why customers should care—especially above the fold. - Test, Don’t Guess
Treat every design or messaging decision as a hypothesis. Test one change at a time, track customer behavior, and let the data guide your next move.
Timestamps:
00:00:00 SEO and Google Ads as First Steps
James recommends structuring a Shopify site for search visibility, creating useful blog content, and testing Google Ads.
00:00:22 Podcast Introduction
The host introduces the show and its focus on helping eCommerce businesses grow.
00:00:35 Meet James and His Shopify Experience
Josh introduces James, CEO of Build Growth Scale, and outlines his experience helping brands scale on Shopify.
00:01:34 Why Amazon Brands Should Expand to Shopify
They discuss diversifying beyond Amazon, improving margins, and using multiple sales channels.
00:03:30 Building a Functional Shopify Store
James recommends starting with a working storefront, connecting fulfillment, and avoiding an Amazon-style layout.
00:06:04 Finding Traffic for a Shopify Store
James suggests beginning with SEO and Google Shopping, then testing other advertising channels.
00:08:17 When to Use Meta Ads
They discuss Meta’s creative demands, retargeting visitors, and the difference between impression- and click-based ads.
00:09:56 Standing Out in an AI-Generated Storefront Landscape
James explains how professional design, real photography, and human touches help build trust.
00:13:08 Improving Store Conversion and Trust
They cover clear value propositions, customer-focused messaging, testing above-the-fold content, and keeping navigation simple.
00:16:03 CRO Myths and Effective Website Practices
James discusses button colors, consistent typography, page purpose, and avoiding automatically added cart charges.
00:20:42 Shopify SEO and AI Search Visibility
They explore Shopify’s AI-related tools, knowledge bases, technical structure, customer questions, and blog content.
00:24:43 Backlinks and Story-Driven Blog Content
James explains the value of authority backlinks and product-focused stories that connect readers to products.
00:26:48 What Helps Shopify Brands Scale
James emphasizes data-driven decisions, customer insights, measured experimentation, and learning from failed tests.
00:28:49 Key Shopify Metrics and Page-Leve l Testing
They review conversion actions for each page, including collection views, product views, add-to-carts, and checkout starts.
00:31:54 Why Brands Fail and How to Test
James discusses listening to customers, prioritizing the biggest opportunities, and accepting risk and failed experiments.
00:34:43Small Changes Versus Full Redesigns
They compare incremental tests for newer brands with larger redesigns for established brands.
00:35:54 Episode Takeaways
Josh summarizes SEO, brand differentiation, and using data to guide focused tests.
00:38:02 James’s Influential Book: The Slight Edge
James explains how small, consistent improvements compound over time.
00:38:43 James’s Favorite AI Tool
James recommends Higgsfield AI for accessing multiple image and video generation models in one platform.
00:39:35 A Person to Follow in eCommerce
James names his mentor and Build Growth Scale owner, Matt Stafford, as someone worth following.
00:40:25 Contacting James and Build Growth Scale
James shares the company website, store analysis tool, and options for booking a consultation.
00:41:02 Closing and Subscribe Message
The show thanks listeners and invites them to subscribe and leave a review.
Resources mentioned in this episode:
- Josh Hadley on LinkedIn
- eComm Breakthrough Consulting
- eComm Breakthrough Podcast
- Email Josh Hadley: Josh@eCommBreakthrough.com
Tools and platforms
Sales and e-commerce platforms
“Amazon“: “00:02:24”
“Shopify“: “00:02:24”
“TikTok Shop“: “00:02:24”
AI and AI-powered commerce
“Claude“: “00:10:42”
“ChatGPT“: “00:21:25”
“Perplexity“: “00:21:25”
“Higgsfield AI“: “00:38:50”
“Kling“: “00:39:27”
“Opus“: “00:39:27”
Books and websites
“The Slight Edge“: “00:38:10”
“BuildGrowScale.com“: “00:40:35”
“Ecomm Breakthrough Website“: “00:40:58”
People and podcast resources
“Matt Stafford“: “00:39:43”
If you’ve hit a plateau and want to know the next steps to take your business to the next level, then email me at josh@ecommbreakthrough.com and in your subject line say “strategy audit” for the chance to win a $10,000 comprehensive business strategy audit at no cost!
Transcript:
James Backenstose 00:00:00 But that would be my first step. SEO builds your site so that it’s structured in a way that LMS can read it. Your blog content is interesting, and then people will want to buy from it. And then dipping your toe into the Google waters.
MC 00:00:22 Welcome to the Ecomm Breakthrough podcast. Are you ready to unlock the full potential and growth in your business? You’ve already crossed seven figures in sales, but the challenge is knowing how to take your business to the next level.
Josh Hadley 00:00:35 Do you want to know what’s working in the world of Shopify right now? Well, today’s guest has all of the answers. Welcome to the Ecomm Breakthrough Podcast. I’m your host, Josh Hadley. I scale my own brand from 0 to 8 figures in sales, and now my mission is to take it to over nine figures on my journey to nine figures. I bring you the unfiltered conversations with the smartest minds in eCommerce. Past guests include Ezra Firestone, Kevin King, and Michael E Gerber, author of the E myth. Today’s guest has spent years helping brands do exactly that, and that is scaling on Shopify.
Josh Hadley 00:01:09 James is the CEO of Build Growth Scale and has been in the e-commerce industry for over a decade, and specifically on the Shopify platform. James has worked with every niche on the planet, and he’s had the blessing to work with every size of client, from start ups to the multiple eight figures, nine figures, and even ten figure brands. With that introduction, welcome to the show, James.
James Backenstose 00:01:32 Thank you. Well, happy to be here.
Josh Hadley 00:01:34 James, you’ve got a wealth of information, especially in the aspect of you have worked with some of the biggest brands that are out there, and I’m sure you’ve got a lot that you could be sharing here. our audience is primarily like people that got started selling on Amazon, but there is a big push to diversify off of Amazon because all of the overseas competitors just ruining pricing on Amazon. Amazon’s raising their fees. There’s a massive amount of margin compression. So Shopify now looks really appealing. It’s the hot girl at the dance along with TikTok shop right now.
Josh Hadley 00:02:11 So James, I am curious, like, what are you seeing on your side? And like, do you ever see it being a successful endeavor to take a brand that started on Amazon and migrating over to Shopify?
James Backenstose 00:02:24 Yes. I totally think it’s a successful endeavor. Not only successful, I think it’s needed. when you selling on Amazon is great, right? It’s a good source of revenue. But that’s not it’s Amazon’s business, not your own. and it’s not one or the other. We we work with people that work with our work on every platform. So it’s not just Amazon or just Shopify. It’s both as well as the hot girl at the dance, as you said, TikTok shops. Another one, you know, multiple channels is the way to grow the brand. and Shopify, obviously your margins will be much, much better than it would be on Amazon. Bezos didn’t become, you know, a multibillionaire off of doing things for free. so, yeah, I see brands not only migrating from Amazon to Shopify, but also going from Shopify to Amazon.
James Backenstose 00:03:19 and the ones that, you know, started at a different path as Shopify, you’re building your business, your brand, and it’s yours. It’s not Amazon’s per se.
Josh Hadley 00:03:30 Yeah. Well, it’s much easier said than done, though, as you know, because I think it’s a completely different skill set to succeed on Shopify. And it requires very different like people involved in that. And I guess that would be my question is like, if somebody is wanting to just start out and get into the game of Shopify, where do you recommend they go? And what is like the first thing that they’ve got to like, solve for?
James Backenstose 00:03:55 Sure. the first thing obviously on shop you’re if you’re selling on Amazon. Amazon’s likely to do in your fulfillment. Right. and Shopify integrates great with all of those fulfillment platforms that Amazon works with. So the first and foremost thing is building a website that that functions and you can sell off of would be the first thing I would do. And possibly the easiest thing, it is a lot easier than people think to build a e-commerce website to get it up and somewhat functional where people can check out.
James Backenstose 00:04:32 so that would be step one. Obviously, as time passes, you’re going to want to tweak the website for conversion rate optimization and make it easier for people to use. But step one would be building that Shopify site. And you can start with Shopify for free. and getting a storefront up and then integrating it with your Amazon fulfillment companies or whoever you may be using. So it’s a very easy step because it’s handling the forward facing customer side. The back end stuff. Fulfillment and shipping. Integrating it with what you already have built and testing the waters would be the first play that I would do. Amazon is a total different landscape, right? If you go to a brand’s Amazon page, like I think they’re a hot mess. If you want me to be bluntly honest, they’re just littered with images. There’s no flow to it. But that’s how Amazon works. So when you build your website, don’t follow the same, you know, structure that Amazon does. just basic CRO best practices. Great image, great product that solves a problem at a great price.
James Backenstose 00:05:47 If you have those things handled on a Shopify store and a button that allows you to purchase, like you can be successful and then you take it from there. Don’t ever try to recreate an Amazon page for an e-commerce storefront. You’ll lose every time.
Josh Hadley 00:06:04 Yeah. No, totally. and I think, like, getting traffic to that storefront is then the next biggest thing is like, how are you going to, like, stop people in their tracks? What are you seeing? I mean, you’ve worked with some of the biggest brands that are out there, but you’ve also worked with some of the seven figure brands. Where do you see like, what’s the best place to go to go get traffic to your storefront in today’s day and age?
James Backenstose 00:06:29 Today, the best place I would start with would be SEO and AEW out the gate. it’s a low cost to get into it. It’s a long play. Right. You can never really just throw up a website and expect to rank on Google in month one.
James Backenstose 00:06:45 That that would be great if that was the process, but that is something I would take care of absolutely. First. That way It’s out of the way. And as long as it’s built correctly with, you know, keyword research and stuff like that, and you have blog articles and your store is set up in the back end for these LMS to read your store, get that out of the way, and then you can move into testing the waters with possibly some free Google Ads. so Google offers free shopping ads. the reach is is smaller, obviously, but that would be my first step. SEO. SEO builds your site so that it’s structured in a way that LMS can read it, your blog content is interesting, and then people will want to buy from it. And then dipping your toe into the Google waters. Obviously, your big ad platforms right now are Google, meta and then TikTok shop. Like you mentioned, meta gets very confusing to target and it’s very creative heavy. But Google, like building some search campaigns, is fairly easy.
James Backenstose 00:07:58 You’re just bidding on keywords. And like I said, they have a free shopping feed. That’s the first step I would do. And then you just experiment from there with low, you know, $10 a day budgets depending on whatever your budget is. But as far as traffic goes, that’s where I would start.
Josh Hadley 00:08:17 Yeah. Are you saying, you know, Facebook meta is almost kind of one of your latter things to add on? It sounds like just because it is such a creative intensive platform.
James Backenstose 00:08:30 It is. It’s a latter one. Unless you’re familiar with the ad platform itself. agencies are obviously going to cost you a good amount of money to have someone do it for you. For meta specifically, Google’s far more user friendly for the owner operator to do. if you do decide to do the meta, the meta route, at the bare minimum, I would run like a retargeting campaigns on meta, which is pretty self-explanatory once you dig into it. Again, it’s their platform that’s confusing on how to use it.
James Backenstose 00:09:03 Not so much the, the theory behind it, but the retargeting campaigns on meta. So the people that do visit your site from organic searches or Google searches will then be targeted, you know, on meta with the retargeting ad which is pulled from your storefront, whether it’s a direct product feed and they’ll see your products again. those are the two starting points for both of those platforms. But when you branch into the cold outreach campaigns on meta itself, it gets a little expensive because you’re paying, you know, for impressions, whereas Google, you’re paying by the click. So that is more important. You’re grabbing the attention with the creatives. So not only do they see it, you’re enticing them to click because you’re going to pay whether they click or not. Google, it’s based off of clicks.
Josh Hadley 00:09:56 Yeah. Makes a lot of sense. so, James, let’s dive into the real meat and potatoes here, which is, you know, we’re moving into this world of like a gigantic commerce. It doesn’t take a whole lot of time for somebody to drum up their own, Shopify storefront.
Josh Hadley 00:10:11 Like, that’s the good news. You’d no longer have to go to these, like, creative agencies and, you know, build out this three month long project to create this beautiful website. Like, it can be done in a day at this point, with AI, but what are you seeing with the advent of AI? How do you differentiate your brand? Still make it unique where, you know, somebody could go rip off your product tomorrow and have a website up and running and meta ads, pump and volume behind it?
James Backenstose 00:10:42 Yes. It’s a it’s a great question. And then a problem that a lot of people have, especially with AI, you can whip up a website with Claude in, you know, 15 minutes and have it live and it’s all fake. So if you rewind, probably eight years ago, the way a store looked didn’t really matter as much as the product did, right? We would work with brand owners eight years ago and we wouldn’t really focus on the the the way the site looked.
James Backenstose 00:11:12 Owners are very tied to how their homepage looks. That didn’t matter then. Now you have to build your sites in such a unique way that they look very professional and outside of what the normal store looks like, because now the one of the largest objections other than price is people need to know, like and trust your brand from the moment they land on it without browsing. So you have to be able to build it in a unique way where it doesn’t look like everyone else. If I go to a website, I can pretty much tell if it’s a Claude built website. The elements are very similar. If it’s going to have an image on the banner with some eyebrow text and a headline right out the beginning, it screams AI to me. So you want to be able to build it in a way that when people land on your website without scrolling, you’re immediately setting yourself apart from the competition. And how you do that is don’t use. I’m a fan of AI imagery. I am, I think it’s great, but don’t use it for everything.
James Backenstose 00:12:23 You have to have a human touch to it, whether it’s with with real video or real photography. Incorporating that in will set you apart from these AI stores. the ones that you know are cash grab type stores and doing that as soon as people land on your page. And so the person can, you know, feel as if they’re talking to a or not or operating a website that there’s an actual human behind it. so you got to kind of get a little fancy with what you do. But again, don’t rely on AI to do everything. It’s not going to work. Well. You have to have the human touch, you know, put into it. So you build that trust right off the land.
Josh Hadley 00:13:08 Yeah. What are some of those, like key aspects that you guys are all about, like conversion rate optimization and overall store performance? What do you see as like the biggest levers that are working today to a build that trust and really boost conversion rates right now on websites? What’s working?
Speaker 4 00:13:28 so when someone.
James Backenstose 00:13:29 Lands on your website, they need to know who you are, what you sell, and why they should buy from you without moving. And we call that a unique value proposition of, you know, especially, like you said, someone can rip off my product today and whip a website up tomorrow, and try to steal my business. So having a unique value proposition. And conveying that to your user right away, whether it’s with UGC user generated content from your actual buyers or photography, or just a simple like a catchy, like a catch phrase for your brand that people can resonate with, landing them right away. So it’s more about the messaging now than it is website functionality per se. In the past, you could add some. We call them UV icons to your site. You know, the free shipping stuff, the made in the USA which are all important now. But it’s you have to relate to the customer, like at an emotional level. It’s kind of hard. It needs brands different, right? so it’s a it’s a tricky, tricky thing to do.
James Backenstose 00:14:43 But that’s why we test things. So if I was to get on a website, I would immediately start testing everything above the fold, from imagery to messaging to two colors per se, and see which one of those resonates with that audience differently. I can take a guess, but testing is kind of like our bread and butter and messaging. Inside of that. Testing matters more now than it ever has.
Josh Hadley 00:15:10 Yeah, no, I think that’s very true. And like what? What sets you apart at the end of the day and making it easy for the customer to understand, like who you are, what you serve, what are your products without having to, like click around a bunch of times? I think that’s a massive.
James Backenstose 00:15:27 Clarity trumps persuasion every single time. just, you know, making your navigation clear, not convoluted is going to be far more powerful than persuading someone to buy your product. It’s a little, little catchphrase that. Matt Stafford, our owner, has used 10,000 times. and it’s.
James Backenstose 00:15:51 What do we usually say? If Homer Simpson can operate your website? You’re doing pretty good. Meaning? Make it. Make it idiot proof. Don’t try to hide things. And it’s. You’ll sell products.
Josh Hadley 00:16:03 Yeah. Fantastic. Really good advice. So, James, what I love is like, I feel like a lot of us that started in the e-com space a decade ago, there was a lot of talk about like, hey, what color your add to cart button should be and different icons you should be using and blah, blah, blah. And it seems like a lot of those things have really changed over the past ten years. What are some of the kind of like common myths that used to be kind of like tried and true CRO principles that have kind of like really shifted in? And what are the tried and true principles today?
James Backenstose 00:16:39 Oh, I love it that you brought up add to cart button colors. The the amount of conversations I’ve had with store owners over a button color is astounding.
James Backenstose 00:16:50 so in the past, you know, everyone went with a green button, green money, they related to it. but now as long as if you’re on a page of a website, each page of a Shopify store has its own function, right? Your home page is to convey what you’re buying and why someone should buy from you. You’re not supposed to sell on it. Right? So the collection page is to break it down for the customer to be able to see those products at a more detailed level, and then filter out the ones that you know they’re interested in. And then the product page is where you’re given the the detailed information about that product. And this is where the button color always comes into play. as long as that button color, because the primary focus of a product page is adding to cart. As long as that button color stands out and it doesn’t blend in to other elements on the page, what color that is doesn’t matter. as long as it’s different, right? When you are looking at a product page, you want your eye to naturally go to whatever the next step is in the journey you want your customer to do.
James Backenstose 00:18:04 So if I land on a product page, that add to cart button should stick out like a sore thumb. Not obnoxiously right, but just in a different element than anything else on the page. And that goes true to any other button on your website. whether it’s a button to submit an email, it should stand out. And those button colors should be consistent throughout the journey from home page all the way to checkout so the user knows if I click, say, a green button, I’m going to go to whatever next step it is. So now as long as is the if the button stands out. That’s always been the case, but what color that button is doesn’t matter as long as it’s on brand. I won’t test a single button color with a client. I’ll just surrender and do whatever the store owner wants as long as it sticks out. So that myth is has totally changed. Another one is the pricing font colors, fonts. Oh my gosh. The amount of conversations I’ve had with font sizes is this astounding as well.
James Backenstose 00:19:13 font consistency through a website truly matters whether your headlines are all 18 pixel. you know, sans serif fonts can group consistency from page to page matters more now than it did before. Meaning like, I want to make sure I feel like I’m on the same website from home page all the way to checkout, and it’s readable. Not this fancy cursive fonts that look pretty, but nobody can read. especially in the AI game, you just want that consistency from start to finish, and people will not feel like they’re on a different website itself. And then, like upsells is another big one. In the past, people used to like, sneak in the, shipping protection in the carts and stuff like that and have it automatically added to your, to your cart. That, and I always thought that was a little sleazy. and people more and more these days will abandon an entire brand or the website if they see that. So it used to be a tactic that worked and it’s not working anymore. People just go buy buy from it.
James Backenstose 00:20:29 and it’s usually a minimal charge. I would much rather give the customer the option to add it rather than, you know, make a customer mad and then get a bad review. But yeah.
Josh Hadley 00:20:42 Yeah. No, those are some really good, really good takeaways. tell me a little bit more. You know, you started this off by saying, hey, one of the first things I would do as a Shopify brand is like, really focus on my SEO. SEO. And, you know, it seems like today blogs are a dying breed, but, you know, to at least to generate traffic, like it’s not about getting ranked in Google anymore, but it is about peppering the the LMS. So tell me, how do you structure that? And if you’re speaking to a store owner that wants to improve their SEO, walk me through how you would recommend that they do that. Something like that.
Speaker 4 00:21:23 okay. So on Shopify.
James Backenstose 00:21:25 Specifically, they are integrated with a genetic e-commerce and ChatGPT and, perplexity.
James Backenstose 00:21:33 I think the other one that they’re integrated with as far as showing your products on those, but more from a technical perspective outside of those native, you know, connections through Magenta and Shopify. It’s new to Shopify. It’s in its infancy still, so they’re still tweaking it, but a lot of it is plug and play. and there’s actually a guide inside of Shopify when you start a Shopify store and you go to the agenda section of the of the admin, it starts with like a knowledge base, which is a file that contains every bit of information about your products, your brand, your store, etc. and it’s just a file in the back end of your store that the LMS can read. It doesn’t really need to be like structured like a blog would. It’s just an endless amount of content. And Shopify itself. You answer some questions inside of the admin, and then it will crawl every page on your website and build the knowledge base for you. so that part’s done. But from more technical perspective, and I’m not a developer, so I may get some of the lingo wrong, but like there’s a robots dot.
James Backenstose 00:22:47 TXT file on a website that has to be built and structured in a way that the LMS can read it. along with that, right, you need to have questions answered on your website. Not typically like an FAQ. So like collection pages on your website should be common questions that everyday people ask about your product and you should give them their answers, not just on the website, but inside of your theme files. It needs to be structured in a way that the LMS can read it. So it’s a two part thing where you’re actually doing the research on your brand, on your products, and figuring out what questions you know people have. And if you say have an Amazon brand already, you’re probably going to have a general idea Of your common questions, and that never really used to be a thing when it came to SEO. SEO a long time ago was, you know, let’s throw some white white font on a white background and just litter the background of the websites so I can rank. That doesn’t work anymore.
James Backenstose 00:23:52 So it does have to be structured in a, in a very precise way. but specifically with Shopify, like I said, outside of the technical aspect of the theme files, and it will walk you through on how to create those inside of Shopify. It’s very plug and play with their agenda, e-commerce. And it’s again, it’s fairly new. but the results I’m seeing, we have a store in the last 90 days, it’s done about $80,000 worth of identical sales. And that’s strictly from just the store being structured from the get go in a way that the lens can read it. I wish I could give a little I’m not a developer, so I can’t get in the in the details of it, but you don’t need to be to do the basics inside of Shopify. Like I said, it’ll walk you right through it.
Josh Hadley 00:24:43 Yeah. how much do you have to focus on, like getting into Reddit or other blogs? you know, to really, like, boost your SEO rankings? Or is it primarily just through your own blog content?
James Backenstose 00:24:58 that one’s ever changing.
James Backenstose 00:25:00 rewind. Six months ago, Reddit was the like. You got to be on Reddit. You got to be on Reddit. Then that kind of disappeared. But one thing that’s remained constant is backlinks. You have to have backlinks and some authority backlinks inside of your content. If you want to truly rank high, that’s remained consistent. in a lot of brands, either they’re featured on these authority links, organically, or they’ll just pay to be featured on it. But it’s you gotta have that part. Still back. Linking is important to rank for both AEW and SEO. That’s been a thing for SEO for for decades, right? and then like the blog articles are great. They’re very content heavy because you’re trying to rank for tons of keywords, and the blog still needs to be interesting written, but we’ve found that if we’re writing a blog article around a story and a specific product is mentioned in that blog, let’s just say I’m writing a blog about me being out in the woods for winning, and I got stuck.
James Backenstose 00:26:10 And I use this specific tow rope, allowing that person to read the story, become connected with it, and then being able to go from that blog directly to that product and buy it. So you’re capturing their attention through the story, and if they’re captured, they’re likely interested in your product. Or in this example, they are off roaders For for this. And then they’re allowed to buy it from the product page. So it’s a variety of things combined into one functional blog per se. so it’s it’s different for every brand.
Josh Hadley 00:26:48 Yeah. Yeah. And it and I think that’s the unique aspect that you have to take is every brand is going to be unique and different, and you have to treat it as such. I think there’s no like cookie cutter approach here. so James, what other things do you have to share for our listeners after having been in the in the space for a decade? What works for Shopify Brands? What’s the differentiator between the brands that scale in the brands that ultimately just kind of like fail or Peter out eventually?
James Backenstose 00:27:22 Oh, that’s actually an easy one.
James Backenstose 00:27:24 And it is the common theme I see every day. Let data drive your decisions and take emotions out of it. The largest hurdle some of these like even medium to large, you know, I’m going to say the big boys, right? The 910 figures. They’ve reached that because they’ve taken their emotions out of the equation. Obviously branding is important aspect. I’m not saying abandon that. It’s extremely important. But what I think, what he thinks and what this other person thinks and feels is meaningless if your demographic doesn’t feel the same way. So when you can take your emotions out of it on what I like and what he likes and just let the data drive your decision making you, that’s what’s going to take you from, you know, six figures to seven. every it’s you would think after, you know, a decade in this, I would find a different common thread between brands. But no, it’s literally the same every single time. And along the the data conversation, because that’s what we do with our partner brands that build growth scale is we get on weekly calls and we go over the data, just the data, and we make decisions based off of that.
James Backenstose 00:28:49 And that’s through like Google Analytics, Microsoft Clarity, Hot Jar for screen recordings, heat maps and stuff like that. But on the Shopify side, Shopify has dumped a lot of money into their the accuracy of their server side data, which it’s becoming more and more accurate every single day. So being able to just look at a report and look at the right data and make a decision from it is the by far the most important aspect. If you want to scale.
Josh Hadley 00:29:22 What are the key numbers you should be looking at then?
James Backenstose 00:29:26 first, like the main numbers I look at on a Shopify store are obviously conversion. Right. That’s the number one. Right? but looking at each page in there. So each page has their own conversion, right? So if I’m doing a test on a product page, my conversion for that test is going to be add to carts. Right. So it’s taking this data and not just running a test trying to increase your conversion rate. We all want to do that right.
James Backenstose 00:29:56 It’s looking at that page’s specific function and optimizing for that. Right. So if it’s a home page test I want people to view the collection page. So that is the metric I use to make a decision on that collection page. I want them to view the product page. So that’s the metric there. Product page functionality you test to look at. Add to cart percentages. Cart functionality. The main functionality is reach checkouts. So that’s the metric there. And then obviously checkout Purchase is is your number one. Let’s get that money. Shopify’s checkout is pretty, you can’t really customize it unless you’re on a Shopify Plus plan, so we rarely do look at that unless it’s on a custom plan. But being able to just look at those one main metric for each page. First and foremost, that’s the route I would go out of the box. You can then start digging deeper into which elements are clicked on your page through through softwares with Google Tag Manager and Google Analytics. But that’s down the line more after you’ve optimized all of these pages for their main the main conversion action on them.
James Backenstose 00:31:15 and that’s paired with like screen recordings and heat maps, being able to watch recordings and see what these users mouse does on the page and what they click on, It’s extremely valuable insights to actually see what people are doing, because you could build something, an element amazing on your page. You know, everyone’s going to love this thing. And then you watch a recording and everyone’s scrolling by it. yeah. So it’s it’s, you know, looking at the data for that one main conversion value on each page and focusing on that and nothing else.
Josh Hadley 00:31:54 Tell me a little bit more about the brands that ultimately fail. What is it that they’re not paying attention to in the data? Because it seems like oh, duh, obvious answer. Like so if it’s as easy as just like follow the data, then everybody should be like hitting nine figure brands on Shopify because just follow the data. So like what is it that’s actually breaking down that like is the true differentiator?
James Backenstose 00:32:21 If I had to put into words brands that Don’t listen to their customer will fail, meaning they’re the customers and your your demographic is going to tell you what they want.
James Backenstose 00:32:37 Listening to your customers is by far the most important, but also not like catering to them at the same time. Right. People are always going to be upset with something on your website, but it’s being able to have the knowledge to take the customer insights and the data and to make the decision about it. So if I can see my add to cart numbers are down, not I as a store owner might not know what to do. and I might try to do 10,000 things at once because I’m hearing this from here and you know this, this is coming at me. So you really got to be able to narrow it down to what is going to move the largest lever. And that’s going to vary brand to brand based on the main customer Objections. and that’s where we come in. Like, we’ve worked with every niche, every brand. So the the, the buyer behavior from an apparel brand is going to be different than, say, the electronics folk. Right. So it’s, it’s a you just got to be able to be able to make the informed decisions based on the data.
James Backenstose 00:33:46 And that can be hard. And you have to be willing to fail. like have to be take risks and fail. There’s some tests you might run, that thing might blow up epically, and you may run it for a day and its numbers are tanking. You have to be able to step away and be okay with losing. I lose more than I win when I test. I’ll say that to anyone. I would love to, you know, get on and just crush test after test, but I don’t. but whether it’s a win or loss, I’m able to take something from that and make an iteration to it. So again, the store owner has to be able to. Willing to take risks and to lose with large changes can come large reward but also can come large loss. So yeah. Risk.
Josh Hadley 00:34:43 Yeah. Yeah. I love that. So you’re almost saying like, small incremental changes can actually be more impactful.
James Backenstose 00:34:52 Correct. Yep, yep. Depending on where the brand’s at. Right.
James Backenstose 00:34:57 when a brand gets if you’re well known, large full page redesigns is the route I would go. But in the starting stages, small incremental ones that focus on one metric would be the best place that I would. I would go for, you know, the least amount of risk. If I’m going to change, say, a button color, will I lose? Probably not as long as it functions right. But you’re also not going to get that big win either with the small. So you have to be able to to, you know, risk it if you risk it if you want the biscuit. I guess you could say you have to be willing to, to just try it and be wrong. a lot of self-righteousness in the e-commerce space with myself included. I have, you know, times that I get that way, but again, willing to take risk.
Josh Hadley 00:35:54 Yeah. Fantastic. Well, James, is there anything I didn’t ask you that you feel like you needed to share with the audience?
James Backenstose 00:36:01 Oh, my gosh, there’s so much.
James Backenstose 00:36:03 no, no, you’ve covered it all.
Josh Hadley 00:36:06 Awesome. Well, James, I love to wrap up every episode with three actionable takeaways. Here are the three actionable takeaways that I noted. You let me know if I’m missing something. Action item number one is on Shopify. Your number one lever that you should be implementing is EO and SEO. And I know everybody like immediately wants to go get that dopamine boost of direct traffic from meta. But the CPMs are very expensive there. And you have to build a full creative team just to support that channel and to make sure it works. And so your lowest hanging fruit really is in the SEO optimizations. That’s step number one. Step number two is differentiate yourself and make something unique. I think in the world of AI, we all call it AI slop. But like there’s a telltale sign now where you can see things where either built with AI or these are AI images. And I think being able to like make yourself differentiated so that you don’t look like everybody else is a big win.
Josh Hadley 00:37:11 And then third, last but not least, everything that you talked about is let data lead your decision making. But make sure that you close the feedback loops. make sure that you’re only testing one variable at a time. Because if you don’t. And I think this goes to like where you’re seeing like the people that succeed versus not is they’re just testing a whole bunch of random stuff, not drawing formal conclusions, and not being able to stair step themselves up into like when after when after when. It’s just like the swinging of the pendulum from one side to another. James, those are the action items that I’ve got for our listeners. Anything else you feel like I missed there?
James Backenstose 00:37:50 No, I think you hit the nail on the head there. summed it up perfectly. Data, data, data. Let data drive the decisions everywhere. With ads, with your storefront, with everything.
Josh Hadley 00:38:02 Fantastic. James, final three questions for you. Number one, what’s been the most influential book that you’ve read and why?
James Backenstose 00:38:10 The Slight Edge.
James Backenstose 00:38:13 it’s a great book. and the reasons why is for years, I always, you know, chased it. We’re all. I chased after the the big money. Right. And I was trying to change my lifestyle and everything in it drastically all at once. And it never worked. And the slight edge is about hitting singles every single time I’m at bat. Small wins compound over time. and and it served me well. so yeah.
Josh Hadley 00:38:43 Great. Question number two. What’s your favorite AI tool that you’ve been using and how have you been using it?
James Backenstose 00:38:50 Ooh, that’s opening up a can of worms there. I would probably want to say clawed, but I’m not gonna, Higgs Field AI, which is a AI image and video generation software that connects to Claude via MCP. But it has, like every model available inside of the software tool to use from cling video, opus, all of it in one spot, because not every single tool does all. Like Claude’s better at this, ChatGPT is better at that.
James Backenstose 00:39:27 And so on and so forth. And Higgs Field AI harnesses all of it into one one platform.
Josh Hadley 00:39:35 Yeah. Great recommendation. Third and final question who is somebody you admire or respect the most in the e-comm space that other people should be following and why?
James Backenstose 00:39:43 Oh, this is a cliche, but I’m going to say Matt Stafford, the owner of Build Growth Scale. he’s just he’s been a mentor to me personally in life because I worked for him, actually, you know, 20 years ago doing concrete work. And he has had the opportunity to work with some very large names in the business. And he’s he’s a store owner and a large person in E-com space that’s not afraid to get his hands dirty and dive in and do the work. And I’m proud to work for him and with him and everyone. Everyone should check him out.
Josh Hadley 00:40:25 Yeah, we’ve had Matt on the podcast, so another good one for people to go look up. well, James, this has been a lot of fun. If people want to reach out to you and connect with you, what’s the best place to do so?
James Backenstose 00:40:35 Build.
James Backenstose 00:40:36 Grow. Com. you can book a call with me, or we have a AI analysis tool on our website where you can plug in some URLs to your Shopify site and get insights on your store based off of the last ten years of the knowledge base that we’ve created. and from there, we can book a call with, with me or one of my colleagues, and we can go through it.
Josh Hadley 00:40:58 Wonderful. Well, James, thanks again for your time today.
James Backenstose 00:41:02 Yes. Thank you, Josh, for having me.
MC 00:41:04 Thank you for listening. Visit Ecomm breakthrough com for more information. If you’ve enjoyed today’s episode, the best way you can show your appreciation is by clicking the subscribe button and quickly leaving a review. See you again next time!

