Your Ecommerce Business Could Be Growing… And Still Be Losing

Josh Hadley

Apple brought in $84.3 billion in its 2018 holiday quarter and still missed its forecast by $6.7 billion. Josh Hadley unpacks what the shortfall revealed: iPhone revenue fell 15%, while wearables grew 33% and services hit a record, making it easy to celebrate the wins and overlook the problem. He connects Apple’s experience to his own struggle to make forecasting a priority, and explains how product-by-product sales targets can expose trouble earlier, sharpen inventory decisions, and push teams beyond easy explanations like “the algorithm changed.” The forecast isn’t a promise you’ll be right; it’s a commitment to pay attention when you’re wrong.

Bullet Points:

  • The importance of forecasting and budgeting for business growth.
  • Setting realistic sales targets by product and time period.
  • Tracking performance against forecasts to spot problems early.
  • Using forecasting to improve inventory planning and supply-chain decisions.
  • Apple’s 2018 holiday-quarter revenue shortfall as a case study.
  • Comparing business results across product categories to identify strengths and weaknesses.
  • Investigating the causes of underperformance, such as lower traffic, conversion, or demand.
  • Turning forecast misses into specific actions and lessons for future growth.

Timestamps:

00:00:00 Why Strong Sales Can Still Mean You’re Losing
Introduces the importance of defining what winning looks like and using forecasts to catch problems.

00:01:04 Why Forecasting Matters to the Host
Josh reflects on relying too much on luck and explains why better budgeting and forecasting are now priorities.

00:02:07 The Detail Behind a Useful Forecast
Explains why businesses should forecast sales by product and time period to guide inventory and spot underperformance.

00:04:33 Apple’s 2018 Holiday Forecast Miss
Introduces Apple’s $84.3 billion quarter, which fell short of its original revenue forecast despite strong sales.

00:05:57 What Small Businesses Can Learn from Public Companies
Argues that businesses of any size can benefit from setting targets and reviewing results against them.

00:08:25 Apple’s Forecast Assumptions and Results
Reviews Apple’s missed expectations, the factors behind the shortfall, and areas that still performed well.

00:11:03 Looking Beyond the Good News
Shows how positive results can distract from major problems and highlights Apple’s response to weaker iPhone upgrades.

00:12:12 Forecasting as a Tool for Responding to Change
Explains that forecasts help teams identify why results differ and choose appropriate actions.

00:13:36 Turning Performance Insights into Business Improvements
Encourages teams to look beyond surface-level explanations and take responsibility for responding to changes.

Links and Mentions:

Other named platforms and media

“Amazon“: “00:03:20, 00:13:36”
“TikTok Shop“: “00:01:04”
“Shopify“: “00:01:04”
“CNBC“: “00:06:05”
“Meta“: “00:13:36”
“Apple’s quarterly earnings reports and investor letter“: “00:04:33–00:12:12”

Transcript:

Josh Hadley 00:00:00  Your business could have its best sales month ever and still be losing in the game because you never defined what winning needed to look like. Today, I’m going to share why even Apple can bring in $84 billion in revenue and still fall short in how to use forecasting to catch problems before they eat your profit. Welcome to the Ecomm Breakthrough podcast I’m Josh Hadley. I’ve scaled my own e-commerce brand from 0 to 8 figures, and I’m actively building towards nine figures in sales. This podcast is where I document that journey and share the systems, the strategies, and the lessons learned in real time so that you can learn what actually matters and scale your own business. My name is Josh Hadley. First and foremost, I am a man of faith. I’m a husband to a beautiful wife and a father of four children. I’ve been selling in the e-commerce space for over a decade now, doing over $20 million in annual revenue and doing multi-million on channels such as Amazon, TikTok, Shop and Shopify. And I am also the host of the number one business strategy podcast called E-com Breakthrough.

Josh Hadley 00:01:04  So today I want to dive into why forecasting is one of the most important things that you and your sales team should be responsible for. And why is this something I have on my mind? Because this is something that I have not done well enough inside of our business. To be honest with you, it’s amazing. Our business has got to where it is today, and I truly believe it’s by the grace of God that I’m still here today. And I’ve shared many of those stories with you, where our back was truly up against the wall. And I believe divine intervention has played a role throughout all of this. But I can’t rely on divine intervention to save my business from just poor judgment calls. If I continue to make them over and over and over again. And so that’s why it is important, as we all kind of learn and grow from grace to grace, we are getting additional enlightenment every day and it is our responsibility as stewards to take that enlightenment and then to go do something different with that enlightenment.

Josh Hadley 00:02:07  So as of late, that enlightenment has been all about budgeting and forecasting. And honestly, like budgeting and forecasting does not sound like a lot of fun. For myself as a fast charging CEO. Like, I want the quick wins. I want the revenue, I want the profit. But I don’t want sitting down to hypothesize what about this? What about that? And then building out a bunch of spreadsheets and financial models? Not as interesting to me, but what I’m learning is it’s vital to the success of the business. Planning the next year is extremely important. And it’s not just like, oh, sit down and have some annual goals. No, no, no. It’s planning. How many units am I selling for every single skew, and how many units am I selling per day, per week, Per month for every single skew. And if you are not creating that level of forecast and budget, then you are flying blind. Like I have been in my business. And it’s also going to lead to poor inventory turnover ratios, which means you’re not moving through your inventory fast enough.

Josh Hadley 00:03:20  It also is going to lead to opportunities where you’re actually underperforming the market and what you are originally selling that same time last year. But your metrics aren’t aren’t tracking it. And so it’s easy for you to lose sales in areas where you are previously winning. But because you don’t have anything that you’re tracking it against, you’re going to lose there. And what I have seen is since we began rolling out, kind of like forecasting for even new product launches or for a lot of our existing products. I am seeing so much better performance across the team because instead of just showing up and being like, oh, how many cells are we going to get today? It’s like, I already kind of know what the next back to school season and next Christmas season is going to look like for us, and you should be planning that and preparing it, because you should be able to know and read the tea leaves much earlier on in the year if things start to veer off, of course, so that that can then impact your overall supply chain process.

Josh Hadley 00:04:33  Maybe you don’t need as much inventory for December because you already saw, hey, this this thing’s going in the wrong direction. So I want to share a very practical example for you. Imagine bringing in $84 billion in one quarter and then having to explain what went wrong, because again, just fun, shiny numbers that sound large doesn’t mean you’re winning. That was Apple after the 2018 holiday season. Apple had forecasted revenue between 89 billion and 93 billion. Its final result was 84.3 billion. It was an enormous number, but nearly 7 billion below the midpoint of its forecast in November of 2018. Apple had every reason to feel confident. It had just finished a record fiscal year. Its September quarterly revenue was up 20%. It had introduced new iPhones, Apple Watches, iPads, Macs. Tim Cook described the lineup heading into the holidays as Apple’s strongest ever. Apple told investors it expected between 89 billion and $93 billion in revenue for the upcoming holiday quarter. That meant roughly 9091 billion at the midpoint. It also laid out expectations for gross margin and operating expenses.

Josh Hadley 00:05:57  There was a financial picture of what the quarter was supposed to produce. Then reality played out differently. So we’re going to talk a little bit more about this story. But the principle is so important. And I remember listening to this like, you have all of these public companies that have these quarterly calls and they’re sharing their quarterly results, and they are sharing like, hey, here’s what Wall Street estimated, right? And here’s what actually resulted, and here’s the CEO’s comments on all of that stuff. I looked at that and I was like, oh yeah, that’s that’s just the game that all the public companies have to play in because like, they have all of these shareholders money and they have to be good stewards of that money and they have to be accountable. So that’s why they’re required to do it. They’re required out of law and out of obligation. And honestly, like I took that as that. That’s a lazy answer to to this situation. I should have seen that as because I love the stock market and I enjoy watching CNBC and all of that stuff.

Josh Hadley 00:07:05  I should have looked at that and said, why am I not creating a forecast and an estimate and having, hey, here is the individual performance. Here’s how many Apple does this, here’s how many iPhones we expect to sell over the next quarter. And then here’s why we’re above or below that expectation. And then, by the way, let’s then have a quarterly earnings report with the team to say what went wrong, what went right, and did we hit our expectations? Did we surpass them? If so, what? What were the tailwinds so that we could go manufacture those over and over and over again? This analogy of like what all the corporate companies are doing or the public companies is exactly what should be happening. Even if you have a small couple million dollar a year business, the aspect of planning and forecasting and budgeting gives you the chance to set a target that’s realistic. And it’s not just wishful thinking of what you hope to sell. There should be some reality baked into it. You say, hey, if if I keep spending this much money in ads and conversion rate stays this amount and based off of, you know, sessions that we believe that we’re going to have, here’s how many units I should be selling.

Josh Hadley 00:08:25  Cool. If something if we overachieve it, I want to know why. And if we underperform against that target. I also want to know why. That’s how business gets better. Like that is the virtuous cycle that if you can learn and then apply those back into your business, that’s how you get compounding growth. Because yes, inevitably you’re going to make mistakes. We’re learning about Apple. They did not hit their expectations okay. So does that mean Apple just like flamed out after this. No, quite the opposite. I’m sure that they took the lessons learned, basically put them back into the business as, hey, do more of this, do less of that. And that’s why they keep compounding year over year over year. And they’re just there. They’re the behemoth that they are today. But into this specific scenario and the story with Apple on January 2nd, 2019, before the releasing of its final earnings report, Tim Cook published a letter telling investors that Apple now expected about $84 billion in revenue.

Josh Hadley 00:09:33  What makes that letter interesting is how specific it was. Apple had it anticipated that the strong dollar would hurt growth. It had anticipated supply constraints on some new products. Those things largely happened as expected. But economic weakness in emerging markets, particularly in China, were worse than what Apple had projected. Customers were also upgrading their iPhones less often than they expected. Cooke pointed out several contributing factors, including higher local prices related to currency movements, fewer carrier subsidies, and customers choosing cheaper battery replacements to keep their existing phones longer. This is where forecasting becomes useful. You have specific assumptions to test which ones held up, which ones broke, and where does management need to respond? Apple’s final results came out on January 29th at $84,000,000,084.3 billion in revenue, and that was 6.7 billion below the midpoint of its original forecasts. It was a miss of 7.4%, but listen to the other numbers from that same quarter. Services revenue hit a record 10.9 billion. Mac revenue grew 9%. The wearables, home and accessories category grew 33%.

Josh Hadley 00:11:03  Earnings per share reached an all time high. Meanwhile, iPhone revenue fell 15% and total company revenue declined 5%. Imagine the meeting you could have if everyone simply showed up and shared their favorite number. Services is setting records. Wearables are growing. Earnings per share are at an all time high. You could spend an entire meeting celebrating legitimate accomplishments and still avoid the biggest issue in the business. That is the bigger thing that you need to take away from Apple. And you could hear with Tim Cook, like he didn’t just say like, yeah, we didn’t meet expectations. The US consumer was just a little more apprehensive. There was weakness in the market like that does nothing. Tim Cook was getting some pretty granular detail and had a running list of reasons why a business can have plenty of good news and still be missing the performance it planned around. Apple also identified actions that it could take. That’s the key. Cooke said that it was accelerating efforts to make phone trade ins. Financing and transferring data easier in old phone could help offset the cost of a new one.

Josh Hadley 00:12:12  Addressing part of the upgrade barrier. That’s the connection that I want you to be able to understand. A forecast forces you to say what you expect to happen and why. Reviewing actual results against it forces you to confront what happened differently. Then you decide what to change. Because if your business misses its sales forecast, was traffic lower than expected? Was conversion weaker? Did customers buy cheaper products? Were you out of stock? Each answer calls for a different decision. And when someone says, why bother forecasting? Because that was honestly me. Things always like, why bother forecasting? Because things are always changing. My response is this. That’s exactly why you need one. You need a clear expectation so that you can recognize the change and respond intelligently. The forecast isn’t a promise that you’ll be right. It’s a commitment to pay attention when you are wrong. That’s the message that I want to share with you. It’s a hard lesson that I’m learning right now, and but it’s a very revealing lesson, and I’m actually excited about it because I think it’s going to increase the flywheel of learning and compounding growth inside of our business, because we’re no longer just going to say like, hey, congrats, our sales are up year over year.

Josh Hadley 00:13:36  Well, why? And if things start trending wrong like because certainly there’s going to be products that outperform. I want to know why those are outperforming. And then there’s going to be products that do not perform. And I want to understand why they’re not performing. I don’t want just like surface level answers as like search results are down. Are more competitors came into the space okay, cool. So what? More competition? What does that mean? We need to change our product format. We needed to do something different, come out with a different product. Because obviously if we’re losing market share, the competitors are doing something right. How do we react. And so that’s the ability that’s the beauty of this forecast. It’s going to force not only you but also your team to just like they cannot stand behind surface level answers as to well, the economy is weak right now. Or Amazon changed their algorithm or meta changed their algorithm. TikTok changed their algorithm. Who cares. What are you going to do? Because that is the result of business.

Josh Hadley 00:14:46  The ball is in your court. You the you are the one who has to take action. I hope you found value in today’s episode. If you did, the biggest thank you I could get from you is by sharing this with another entrepreneur that needs to hear the same message. And until next time, good luck out there.